By Maria Golarz, Senior Associate Research Lawyer, Lam Family Law*
The Court of Appeal for Ontario (“ONCA”)’s recent decision in MacEwen v. Daljit, 2026 ONCA 398 (CanLII), is an important reminder that courts will generally uphold negotiated separation agreements unless there is a compelling legal basis to set them aside. The decision also reinforces fundamental principles of procedural fairness, particularly where allegations of dishonesty, deception, or fraud are raised.
Background
The parties separated in 2015 after a 12-year marriage and negotiated a separation agreement with the assistance of a divorce consultant. The wife received Independent Legal Advice (“ILA”); the husband did not: paras 7-15. In addition to the sale of the matrimonial home, the agreement addressed division of the sale proceeds, equalization, calculation of income, and child and spousal support: para 16.
Two years later, with the matrimonial home sold and the agreement partially implemented, the husband challenged the agreement’s validity: paras 17-19. At a focused hearing, he argued that two provisions had been altered from an earlier draft and that he did not understand or agree to those changes: paras 21 & 24-28.
The hearing judge accepted the husband’s position and set aside the entire agreement under s. 56(4)(b) of the Family Law Act, RSO 1990, c F.3 (“FLA“). However, the hearing judge rejected the husband’s arguments. Instead, the court relied on its own theory that the wife engaged in “trickery” by making unilateral changes to the agreement without the husband’s knowledge, and set aside the agreement: paras 34-39. The wife appealed.
ONCA Finds Procedural Unfairness
The ONCA unanimously allowed the wife’s appeal and re-instated the agreement. A central issue was the manner in which the hearing judge arrived at the conclusion that the wife had acted dishonestly. The ONCA held that the finding of “trickery” was procedurally unfair because it was neither pleaded nor advanced by the husband: paras 43-47 & 59.
The ONCA emphasized several fundamental litigation principles:
- Parties are entitled to know the case they are expected to meet: paras 49-50;
- Pleadings define the boundaries of litigation: para 50;
- Parties wishing to challenge a witness’s evidence must do so in cross-examination: para 51; and
- Parties (not the court) articulate the case to be met. Judicial reasons should therefore respond to the case advanced by the parties, not a judicial theory: para 52.
The ONCA found that the hearing judge introduced his own theory that the wife had “slipped in” changes to the agreement, and then guided counsel’s closing submissions toward that theory: paras 53-56. The husband never pled allegations of fraud, trickery, or deception, nor was the wife put on notice. The husband’s counsel did not put such allegations to the wife during cross-examination: paras 54-57.
The ONCA has routinely held that deciding a case on a basis not anchored in the pleadings, evidence, or party submissions “displaces deference and warrants appellate intervention”: para 58. As a result, the hearing judge’s findings could not stand: para 59.
Clarifying the Test Under S. 56(4)(b) of the Family Law Act
The ONCA further used the appeal as an opportunity for a detailed review of the legal framework governing s. 56(4)(b) of the FLA. Subsection 56(4)(b) permits a court to set aside a domestic contract where a party “did not understand the nature or consequences” of the agreement: paras 61-64.
The ONCA reaffirmed the two-step analysis previously set out in LeVan v. LeVan, 2008 ONCA 388 (CanLII):
- 1. The party challenging an agreement or a term within it must establish that one of the grounds set out in s. 56(4) are engaged; and
- 2. The court must then determine whether it is appropriate to exercise its discretion to set aside the agreement: para 65.
A party claiming under s. 56(4)(b) must establish that they did not understand the “nature” of the agreement or they did not understand its “consequences”. Failing to understand the “nature” of the agreement refers to a failure to understand either the type of contract being entered into, or specific terms of the contract. Failure to understand the “consequences” refers to a failure to understand either the practical or legal effects of the contract or one or more of its terms: paras 66-67.
In applying the two-step approach under s. 56(4)(b), the relevant considerations can be organized into three broad categories:
1. Personal vulnerabilities may include:
- Language barriers;
- Significant mental or physical health issues;
- Lack of sophistication; and
- Power imbalances or other inequalities within the relationship: paras 68-69, citing various cases.
2. External pressures may include:
- Pressure not to obtain ILA or resulting in inadequate or conflicted ILA;
- Financial, professional, or emotional pressure(s);
- Time constraints (perceived or actual); and
- Misrepresentations about the nature, purpose, or consequences of the agreement: para 70, citing various cases.
3. Procedural safeguards may include:
- Full and frank financial disclosure;
- Timely and comprehensive ILA;
- Other professional support, such as adequate translation or accounting assistance: para 71, citing various cases.
These factors are not exhaustive. All factors, however, may be relevant to a “holistic determination” of whether s. 56(4) is engaged, as well as whether the court should exercise its discretion to intervene. The absence of the procedural safeguards listed above will not necessarily be fatal to a domestic contract. Conversely, their presence will not necessarily immunize a contract: para 72.
Personal Responsibility Still Matters
One of the more significant aspects of the decision is the ONCA’s discussion of personal due diligence in making agreements. The ONCA emphasized that “[i]nherent in the autonomy recognized by permitting parties to contract out of the legislative scheme through a domestic contract is an element of personal due diligence.” Courts recognize a party’s obligation to take reasonable steps, within their capacity and control, and recognizing any vulnerabilities or pressures, to protect and advance their own interests: paras 73-74.
At a minimum, parties should:
- Fully and carefully read the domestic contract before signing;
- Clarify terms where necessary; and
- Take steps to remedy known deficiencies in the domestic contract: para 74.
A party who chooses not to take these steps may later face difficulty trying to resile from the contract: para 74.
The relevant time to assess the impact of any asserted factors is during the negotiations and at execution of the contract, not at the time of the claim. Further, the court will also consider the complexity and purpose of the agreement; any delays in moving to set it aside and any reasons for same; whether part or all of the contract has already been implemented; and any benefits already realized by the claimant. Overall, this is a “highly discretionary exercise entitled to significant deference”: paras 75-77.
Why the Husband’s Challenge Failed
In MacEwan v. Daljit, after removing the hearing judge’s unsupported finding of dishonesty, the ONCA found there was no basis to conclude that the husband failed to understand the nature or consequences of the agreement. The hearing judge had not identified any personal vulnerabilities, inequality of bargaining power, or lack of sophistication on the part of the husband. The hearing judge rejected the husband’s claims that he was pressured, vulnerable, or exploited by the wife. The husband had been repeatedly told to obtain ILA and chose not to. He had also failed to ask for further disclosure in the days prior to signing the agreement. In the circumstances, the statutory requirements for setting aside the agreement had not been established, and the wife’s appeal to re-instate the agreement was allowed: paras 78-81 & 86.
Key Takeaways
- 1. Separation Agreements Remain Difficult to Set Aside: negotiated domestic contracts should be respected absent compelling reasons to intervene.
- 2. Read Before You Sign: parties are expected to review agreements carefully and understand their contents before execution. And, while the absence of ILA is not automatically fatal, parties who decline repeated recommendations to obtain legal advice may face significant challenges later if they attempt to challenge an agreement.
- 3. Serious Allegations Must Be Properly Pleaded: Claims involving fraud, deception, or dishonesty must be expressly pleaded and put to witnesses. Courts cannot decide cases on theories that were never advanced by the parties.
*with thanks to Rebecca Winninger and Sierra Larmand for their suggestions and edits.
This blog is informational only and should not be relied on as legal advice.

Leave a Reply